Marcus Foster

Pennsylvania Flirts with Lowering Education Standards

Imagine a referee changing the rules for “what counts” as a win after the final buzzer sounds. That’s precisely what the Pennsylvania Department of Education (PDE) is considering doing for the statewide standardized tests.

State officials proposed changing how they score student performance on state math and reading tests, making it easier for students to qualify as “advanced” on both the K-8 PSSA and the high school Keystone exams. If adopted, the change would have lowered the scores students need to reach “advanced” in nearly all grades. And it would apply retroactively to tests students took months ago.

Fortunately, the state board voted down the change in standards. But the proposal does raise some important concerns about Pennsylvania education.

Same Test, New Results

Students sat for the 2026 exams last spring, but PDE wants to rewrite the grading rules after the fact. That makes it nearly impossible to tell whether students are improving. When the yardstick moves between measurements, you’re left with an apples-to-oranges comparison.

Officials say the change is overdue. The state last changed these thresholds in 2015 as part of an overhaul of educational standards, and officials have said they always intended to review reading and math standards.

Reviewing standards is reasonable. Applying a new grading rule to unpublished test results invites serious questions. What were state officials trying to hide?

The Cost of Waiting

The state normally releases these scores to the schools in August and to parents in November. Officials acknowledged that the score review contributed to the wait.

Families are paying for the delay. Philadelphia is now accepting applications for its selective schools, but families can’t see the results needed to gain admission to highly coveted magnet schools. That is a lot of anxiety for kids and parents, caused by an avoidable delay.

The testing season itself was also bumpy. This year was the first spring of online testing, but a statewide outage disrupted the exams. Delayed scores plus shifting thresholds mean no one can separate how much of any result reflects learning and how much reflects technical trouble.

The Scores That Matter

Under the old standards, the 2025 numbers were sobering. In elementary reading, 51 percent of students scored Basic or Below Basic and only 13 percent scored Advanced. In elementary math, 58 percent scored Basic or Below Basic and just 17 percent scored Advanced.

Lowering the bar for “advanced” won’t improve a single kid’s ability to read or perform math.

What Should Happen Next

Pennsylvania families deserve transparency and meaningful results.

At a minimum, PDE should publish this year’s scores under both the old and new metrics, so parents and taxpayers can see the real trend.

Better yet, state leaders should expand options for students and families. Kids who aren’t being served well by their assigned schools need options now. The quality of a child’s education shouldn’t depend on their zip code or their income. That’s why tax-credit scholarships—from Pennsylvania’s popular statewide programs to the new Federal Scholarship Tax Credit—matter: They give families the financial resources to find better schools.

Kids don’t need lower standards. They need more choices.