The Battle for Worker Freedom: Grading State Public Sector Labor Laws

Download PDF

Key Findings

  • Union executives are prioritizing recruitment. The fastest-growing category of public sector labor legislation expands collective bargaining into new workplaces.
  • On the strength of these new laws, union executives are slowly replacing their membership losses since 2018. From 2018 to 2025, the country’s four largest government unions report a net decline in membership of 87,919, or 1.3 percent. However, they also report a collective gain of 232,502 members, or 3.5 percent since 2024.
  • This report awards full letter-grade increases to Idaho (now A) and Louisiana (now B) due to their adoption of pro-worker labor reforms this past legislative session. However, the drops in grades—Nebraska (D), Nevada (D), and Rhode Island (F)—are the result of these states prioritizing union executives over workers and enacting laws helping unions recruit, politick, organize, and strike.
  • Thirteen states now have an “A” or “A+” grade—up from twelve in the previous edition of this report—while six states earned an “F”—up from five over the same time period. Overall, the research finds 25 states fall below a “C.”

State Grades

More in-depth state profiles are available in the full report.

GRADENUMBER OF STATESSTATES
A+7Arkansas, Georgia, Indiana, North Carolina, South Carolina, Tennessee, and Texas
A6Florida, Idaho, Iowa, Mississippi, West Virginia, and Wisconsin
B10Alabama, Arizona, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, North Dakota, Oklahoma, Utah, Virginia, and Wyoming
C2Missouri and South Dakota
D15Alaska, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Maine, Michigan, Minnesota, Montana, Nebraska, Nevada, New Hampshire, New York, Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Vermont
D-4Hawaii, Massachusetts, New Jersey, and New Mexico
F6California, Illinois, Maryland, Oregon, Rhode Island, and Washington